diff --git a/src/ScreenGameplayShared.cpp b/src/ScreenGameplayShared.cpp
index 21b656648e..aab8ab80a5 100644
--- a/src/ScreenGameplayShared.cpp
+++ b/src/ScreenGameplayShared.cpp
@@ -17,8 +17,8 @@ void ScreenGameplayShared::FillPlayerInfo( vector<PlayerInfo> &vPlayerInfoOut )
 	/* The master player is where all of the real work takes place.  The other player exists
 	 * only so we have a place to split stats out into at the end. */
 	vPlayerInfoOut.resize( 2 );
-	vPlayerInfoOut[0].Load( master, MultiPlayer_Invalid, true, Difficulty_Invalid );
-	vPlayerInfoOut[1].Load( other, MultiPlayer_Invalid, false, Difficulty_Invalid );
+	vPlayerInfoOut[master].Load( master, MultiPlayer_Invalid, true, Difficulty_Invalid );
+	vPlayerInfoOut[other].Load( other, MultiPlayer_Invalid, false, Difficulty_Invalid );
 }
 
 PlayerInfo &ScreenGameplayShared::GetPlayerInfoForInput( const InputEventPlus& iep )