diff --git a/src/InputMapper.cpp b/src/InputMapper.cpp
index 6707cf8408..90e65ae879 100644
--- a/src/InputMapper.cpp
+++ b/src/InputMapper.cpp
@@ -948,7 +948,7 @@ MultiPlayer InputMapper::InputDeviceToMultiPlayer( InputDevice id )
 GameButton InputScheme::ButtonNameToIndex( const RString &sButtonName ) const
 {
 	for( GameButton gb=(GameButton) 0; gb<m_iButtonsPerController; gb=(GameButton)(gb+1) ) 
-		if( sButtonName.EqualsNoCase(GetGameButtonName(gb)) )
+		if( stricmp(GetGameButtonName(gb), sButtonName) == 0 )
 			return gb;
 
 	return GameButton_Invalid;