diff --git a/Themes/_fallback/BGAnimations/ScreenSelectProfile overlay.lua b/Themes/_fallback/BGAnimations/ScreenSelectProfile overlay.lua
index 03141d7451..8f850e2ddb 100644
--- a/Themes/_fallback/BGAnimations/ScreenSelectProfile overlay.lua	
+++ b/Themes/_fallback/BGAnimations/ScreenSelectProfile overlay.lua	
@@ -207,7 +207,7 @@ local t = Def.ActorFrame {
 				SCREENMAN:GetTopScreen():Finish();
 			end;
 		end;
-		if params.Name == 'Up' then
+		if params.Name == 'Up' or params.Name == 'Up2' then
 			if GAMESTATE:IsHumanPlayer(params.PlayerNumber) then
 				local ind = SCREENMAN:GetTopScreen():GetProfileIndex(params.PlayerNumber);
 				if ind > 1 then
@@ -218,7 +218,7 @@ local t = Def.ActorFrame {
 				end;
 			end;
 		end;
-		if params.Name == 'Down' then
+		if params.Name == 'Down' or params.Name == 'Down2' then
 			if GAMESTATE:IsHumanPlayer(params.PlayerNumber) then
 				local ind = SCREENMAN:GetTopScreen():GetProfileIndex(params.PlayerNumber);
 				if ind > 0 then
diff --git a/Themes/_fallback/metrics.ini b/Themes/_fallback/metrics.ini
index 1d1ad9592e..0bbfd95712 100644
--- a/Themes/_fallback/metrics.ini
+++ b/Themes/_fallback/metrics.ini
@@ -1511,9 +1511,11 @@ StartScreen=Branch.AfterSelectProfile()
 #
 TimerSeconds=40
 #
-CodeNames="Up,Down,Start,Back"
+CodeNames=SelectProfileKeys()
 CodeUp="+MenuUp"
+CodeUp2="+Up"
 CodeDown="+MenuDown"
+CodeDown2="+Down"
 CodeStart="Start"
 CodeBack="Back"
 
diff --git a/Themes/default/BGAnimations/ScreenSelectProfile overlay.lua b/Themes/default/BGAnimations/ScreenSelectProfile overlay.lua
index c24eb8b3e7..df149c6cda 100644
--- a/Themes/default/BGAnimations/ScreenSelectProfile overlay.lua	
+++ b/Themes/default/BGAnimations/ScreenSelectProfile overlay.lua	
@@ -202,7 +202,7 @@ local t = Def.ActorFrame {
 				SCREENMAN:GetTopScreen():Finish();
 			end;
 		end;
-		if params.Name == 'Up' then
+		if params.Name == 'Up' or params.Name == 'Up2' then
 			if GAMESTATE:IsHumanPlayer(params.PlayerNumber) then
 				local ind = SCREENMAN:GetTopScreen():GetProfileIndex(params.PlayerNumber);
 				if ind > 1 then
@@ -213,7 +213,7 @@ local t = Def.ActorFrame {
 				end;
 			end;
 		end;
-		if params.Name == 'Down' then
+		if params.Name == 'Down' or params.Name == 'Down2' then
 			if GAMESTATE:IsHumanPlayer(params.PlayerNumber) then
 				local ind = SCREENMAN:GetTopScreen():GetProfileIndex(params.PlayerNumber);
 				if ind > 0 then